Theres no doubting his class; its just that Keane was narrowly better. And while the balance of honours sways convincingly in Keanes favour, it is as individuals that each man is best judged. The ferocity of their head-to-head meetings sometimes overshadowed how complete they were as midfielders. Source () - Own work5. Keane left United later that year. "Out of nowhere, all these security men appeared," wrote Savage in his autobiography. Pascal TV 494 subscribers Subscribe 1.1K views 2 years ago Roy Keane VS Patrick Vieira. For Keane, that meant pre-match revenge. "I could hear these footsteps behind me and Vieira shouting, 'Neville! Patrick Vieira and Roy Keane are two of the best midfielders in Premier League history and together were at the heart of the league's greatest rivalry between Manchester United and Arsenal. at Vieira, Keane actuallyhas to be restrained by Poll, who urges the United captain to calm down before taking to the pitch. After retiring, both have tried their hand at management. Patrick would've been my toughest opponent at the time. 'Win the game - get in and get out'. FREE TO PLAY: Do not miss your chance to land the 250,000 jackpot on Tuesday, for the fifth time this year! The key for me after that is don't be distracted by it. File ( ) - Roy keane 2014.jpg2) Patrick Vieira1. In the first episode Thierry Henry went head-to-head with Dennis Bergkamp. Like me, he wants to win and we have had some good battles. FourFourTwo is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. I loved every aspect of his game. As he returns to Old Trafford today for the first time as a manager, the current Crystal Palace boss may well be met by jeers. Goals against per game: 1.42, Vieira vs Keane a rivalry like no other pic.twitter.com/FfXpmK8bFx, GoonerNick (@nickvann1987__) February 25, 2021, Points per game: 1.41 Another man not a stranger to disciplinary problems, Vieira was the captain of Arsenal's unprecedented "Invincible" season. They were leaders in the most obvious sense, warriors for their respective teams and macho in the extreme. The Frenchman made a strong start, as Guardian scribe David Lacey noted: Keane and Beckham took a while to establish parity with Bergkamp and Vieira but once this had been achieved, United tore at Arsenals defence ferociously. Keane ended the campaign clutching his third title winners medal but, with Arsenal clearly in the ascendancy following the mid-season appointment of Arsene Wenger, it was clear a new challenge loomed. United responded 10 minutes later with a deflected Ryan Giggs goal, but Arsenal re-claimed the lead before the break thanks to a thumping Bergkamp finish. The latters conversion turned out to be the final kick of his Arsenal career, with a move to Juventus soon completed. Television cameras were perfectly placed to capture the moment, peering down the cramped Highbury tunnel as Keane took exception to something Vieira had said. Click here to see more duels by this author. There was only one direct head-to-head between the two, in Uniteds swashbuckling 2-1 win at Highbury in February 1997, an evening when both men were flanked by unexpected central midfield partners: David Beckham alongside Keane, Dennis Bergkamp next to Vieira. Those who claim Vieira is the more pivotal player could note that Arsenal have failed to win a single trophy since his departure, while United have claimed several in the post-Keane era. Date ( ) - 3 March 20146. They came up against each otherplenty of times in many heated confrontations, but the most memorable clash between Keane and Vieira came on February 1, 2005 at Arsenal's former homeHighbury. Vieira, in contrast, won three leaguetitles and three FA Cups - the last of which, in 2005, came at the expense of Keane's United. United won the game 4-2, and interestingly neither protagonist was booked. Will play in the Champions League final after being cruelly denied in 1999 by suspension, after that Barcelona goal, no body deserves it more. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright . The two were warriors, constantly trying to outdo one another on the pitch, both unafraid to go in hard and to demand the very best of their team-mates. View full stats. That has to count for something. Vieira added a Coppa Italia. Vieira won seven league titles in total, four of which came during his stint with Inter. On 1 February 2005, Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira had their famous run-in in the Highbury tunnel Just when it seemed that the enmity had evolved into a healthy mutual respect with well-defined boundaries, 2004/05 came along. There are fair questions about how their games would have aged. Player Duels returns for a second installment. Roy keane clashes with patrick vieira in the highbury tunnel. He then went into assistant manager roles with Ireland, Aston Villa, and Nottingham Forest. Uniteds no.16 reacted with a kick after his Arsenal counterpart had charged into him, prompting the defining image of the rivalry: the pair together, again with foreheads pressed, neither giving an inch. His passing was underrated, too. The culmination, of course, was the infamous tunnel exchange between the pair which ended on Keanes warning: Well see you out there. Though Vieira quickly opened the scoring with his second career goal against the Reds, Keane ended the evening victorious, playing peerlessly as United came back to win 4-2. I heard John [Charles] shouting to me to hold on to my passport. For more information on support tools, please visit our Responsible Gambling page, best Premier League midfielders of all time. They were just great lads who were well grounded. They have long since retired from playing, but Manchester United fans and Arsenal fans both lament the fact that they don't have players like Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira any more. His decision to leave Arsenal in the summer of 2005, followed five months later by Keanegs departure from Manchester United to Celtic, brought a dramatic change in the landscape of the Premier League. A rather comic chase ensued, with half the Inter team chasing Navarro up the tunnel and trying to trip him up. Sterling vs Cejudo: The key stats . Vieira just about has the edge, but picking between the two is every bit as challenging as deciding between Frank Lampard and Steven Gerrard or John Terry and Rio Ferdinand. He was a good player and I knew I had to be at my best when I was up against him. They were brilliant team-mates. The value which football fans will place on something so subjective, so unquantifiable, is going to vary. United and Arsenal have been the two most consistent teams in England over the past decade because theyve got Keane and Vieira, noted Liverpool skipper Steven Gerrard. 10 - Ireland U21. In his pomp, Keane had an unrivalled engine enabling him to contribute all over the field. Premier League Manchester United Arsenal . That was because he was suspended for four games over a series of incidents during a group game against Colombia: initially he was sent off for a clash with assorted opposition players, then on his way off the pitch he kicked a ball at Paolo Amero and headbutted Jason Murillo. Career Comparison. Maybe we would have seen even more of Vieira as an attacking force if given greater license to get forward from a midfield three. ", Gary Neville on Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira's famous tunnel spat pic.twitter.com/e8pGo1ZcSn, "I just felt they were bullying Gary," Keane later reflected in his book The Second Half. That precious combination of leadership and complete midfield talent shapes a team the Gunners and Red Devils were as successful as they were because of the presence of Keane and Vieira. I go back to Steven Gerrard and the Frank Lampard. Vieira, in contrast, won three leaguetitles and three FA Cups - the last of which, in 2005, came at the expense of Keane's United. Goals against per game: 1.34, Keane and Carra kicking off panto season was TV at its best, Sorry Vieira, Roy Keane vs Vinnie Jones was the ultimate clash of the titans, Arsenals 16 Patrick Vieira replacements and how they fared, Seven reasons why Patrick Vieira will always be an Arsenal legend. Alex Ferguson's men had propelled themselves into a good positionbut, with 20 minutes to go, they were reduced to 10 men after Mikael Silvestre was deemed to have butted heads with Freddie Ljungberg. Claimed an unprecedented 10th Premier League title this. He also returned for a brief spell with Manchester City for the final two seasons of his playing career. The referee, Graham Poll, intervenedto quell the disturbance, but Keane had not said his piece. Dillon leaves United on a permanent basis as he switches to the Bundesliga. That Keane suffered a career-threatening cruciate ligament injury in the 1997/98 season underlines what a great player he really was. Manchester United won the game, beating Arsenal 4-2. Matches, Goals, Assists, Cards & More. Scores vital goals at the right time. Thus, when the sides reconvened for the Premier League return at Highbury two months on, all parties were suitably amped up in advance. When all was said and done, though,Keane narrowly edgedVieira when the pair faced off. Debut . He (Vieira) sort of squirted his water bottle towards Roy, then all hell broke loose. So who is the greatestmidfielder in EPL history? The latter was also included in the Premier Leagues Team of the Decade for its first 10 years. There is not really any hatred between the two groups of players of the sort that existed between the likes of Patrick Vieira and Roy Keane, though it is admittedly a different story in the dugouts. An image is firmly set in the mind: that of Keane racing 30-40 yards to dispossess Vieira in another of their titanic tussles. Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira discussing the infamous tunnel incident at Highbury in 2005 #MUFC pic.twitter.com/ZIapyMnEFp. Not many midfielders have impacted Premier League predictions quite like Vieira and Keane. However, his talent is unquestionable. Reports suggested that Jose Mourinho was forced to wipe milk off his face, though sources told ESPN FC that no milk or water were thrown, and Mikel Arteta, caught in the crossfire, reportedly emerged with a cut to his eye, with bottles reportedly flying around. Vieiras managerial career is a lot more fresh in the memory with him currently being Crystal Palace manager after taking over from Roy Hodgson. He could stick the ball on a stamp and he also had the small matter of that free kick. May 22, 1991. The offences to be taken into consideration include major riots at home (vs Birmingham in 2002 and Ipswich in 1978) and away (against Luton in 1985, QPR in 1966, plus West Ham in 1906 and 2009). Vieira did not back down in any situation. There are 10 Premier League title triumphs and many other medals between the two. Bryan Robson emerged with a gashed arm, and everyone else just about got out alive. Therein lies a crucial difference between the two; where Vieira played an influential role in victories, he was less likely to raise his game (and those of his team-mates) by that extra level in the clutches of defeat. 1 /1 Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira relive rivalry - after the former. Neither would give an inch. Through illness, the United skipper sat out his sides 2-0 home win, which preceded unsightly scenes post-match as Arsenal players, incensed at the controversial end of their 49-game unbeaten league run, found some solace in flinging post-match pizza. We're as amazed as you. At half-time, Alpay kept up the wind-up, leading to Beckham chasing him down the tunnel and England's security man stepping in to calm things down. After a serious of dubious refereeing decisions from Gerhard Schulenberg, the Derby bosses suspected that something was afoot, a suspicion reinforced when they spotted Juve striker Helmut Haller go into the referee's room both before the game and at half-time. He would challenge you in different ways. It was great. The title pendulum continued to swing between Old Trafford and Highbury, with United retaining it in 1999/2000 and 2000/01, Arsenal regaining it in 2001/02, United likewise in 2002/03, and Arsenal going unbeaten for the season to take it once more in 2003/04. I used to enjoy it and I think both players enjoyed it too.. I had huge respect for him, but I knew if I could win my battle it would give us a better chance of winning the game. But years later people bring up the tunnel and they don't remember the match that came after it.". Keane had a tendency to tread the line between aggressive and foul play. It depends on who you ask and opinions vary - usually depending on which side of the Manchester United-Arsenal divide you are on. The manager would remind us every now and again before we'd go into certain big games, you are in the trenches are you happy with the lads around you? Beforehand, the Gunners talisman admitted: I like to play against Roy Keane. Roy Keane Rockmount AFC (1981-1989) Patrick Vieira FC Trappes (1984-1986), FC Drouais (1986-1991), FC Tours (1991-1993) Stats Roy Keane View full stats Patrick Vieira View full stats National team career Roy Keane Go to national player profile Patrick Vieira Go to national player profile Teammates All games played together The former Arsenal captain was dismissed earlier this month due to an alarming winless run. It was Keane who laughed last the following month, however, when he rolled back the years with a dominant display as United reached the FA Cup final at the expense of Vieiras champions-elect. They came up against each other 12 times in the Premier League, with Keane and Man United emerging victorious on four occasions, losing three times, and they could not be separated in five games. Neither player took a step back. So, ladies and gentlemen, who is your pick? As part of Alex Ferguson's all-conquering Manchester United teams, Keane won seven Premier League titles and four FA Cups. They were hard-tackling, but both had much more to their games. Author () - Simon Heseltine4. Both won four FA Cups. Ultimately Navarro was banned by UEFA for seven months, and both clubs were fined around 100,000. In September 2006, looking ahead to Arsenals visit to Old Trafford, Sir Alex Ferguson allowed his focus, invariably set purely on the future, a cursory flicker to past events. How will Mauricio Pochettino set up at Chelsea if named as club's new manager? Amidst the bigger picture of both sides relentless march for silverware, the Keane-Vieira subplot proved consuming, with Richard Williams of The Independent writing: Keanes bone-shuddering battles with Vieira have been something extraordinary to behold and the best possible advertisement for maintaining a degree of physical contact in football.. But this one was a hangover from Manchester United's win over Arsenal in 2004, when they stopped the "Invincibles'" unbeaten run thanks to some pretty rough treatment. Roy Keane VS Patrick Vieira. ', Transfer Centre LIVE! These are players not only irreplaceable in skillset, but also in personality. Tottenham Hotspur vs Manchester United live stream, match preview, team news and kick-off time for this Premier League match, Southampton vs Bournemouth live stream, match preview, team news and kick-off time for this Premier League match, Everton vs Newcastle United live stream, match preview, team news and kick-off time for this Premier League match, Manchester City vs Arsenal live stream, match preview, team news and kick-off time for this Premier League match. They showed that you could polish a . Although he has performed miracles in the EPL, the ex-Wales international will be remembered for his strike against Arsenal in the FA Cup. Copyright 2023, the 888 Group. You had to be at your best. It would be equally disingenuous to boast that Vieira won a World Cup and a European Championship. In a League Cup semifinal in 2006, a minor disagreement on the pitch turned into something spicier at half-time. Heres how it works. "Roy Keane against Patrick Vieira was an incredible competition between two titans of the game," commented the Scot, surveying the legacy of a nine-year rivalry which had come to a close in. I would've had to have changed my game, whoever was coming through because I was getting a bit older. And when Keane later barged over Marc Overmars and saw Vieira encouraging referee Graham Barber to mete out censure, Keane shared his thoughts with his French opponent from a sub-millimetric distance. The Gunners strode to a league and FA Cup Double in 1997/98, exploiting a leg-weary, injury-depleted United side for whom Keane missed nine months of the season with cruciate ligament damage. Career. So, I said, lets see if we can do that again tonight. And he [Vieira] just went: Not tonight, Graham. Vieiras focus manifested in warning Gary Neville beforehand that he was in trouble. Had Vieira replaced Keane, a similar triumph would be perfectly conceivable. But how do their senior managerial statistics stand up against one another? Keane and Vieira were unquestionably the most revered box-to-box central midfielders the Premier League has witnessed. 2nd virginia regiment revolutionary war roster,