However, it's a little bit more reserved than his 2019 quote with TMZ, and he even mentioned two others he feels deserve an opportunity this time around. Seymour went to two more Pro Bowls in his 30s with the Raiders to close a mighty 12-year career. Its a loaded running back class, however, and other positions like wide receiver, offensive line and defensive back seem loaded as well. He never quite made it to that level, which is to say that I don't think there was a time when he was ever the best quarterback in the National Football League. Branch was one of the smoothest big-play receivers ever to play, and he deserves to be in Canton with his late quarterback, Ken Stabler. While the last couple decades havent been incredibly kind to Syracuse Orange football, that doesnt mean the programs history is lost on us or the Pro Football Hall of Fame, apparently. Its time for McNabb to get his props and be in the Hall of Fame. Although theres a case for quarterback Jim Hart and perhaps some sentimental push for the late Pat Tillman, Wilson is thechoice. The browser you are using is no longer supported on this site. I won't go into all statistical reasons for why McNabb was a top-tier QB, but here are a few. This is another thing entirely: The NFL having Derrick Brooks introduce Cliff Branch when Ronde Barber was nominated for the Hall of Fame (and snubbed) as a red herring was just cruel, Brandon Thornton (@BThornton_33) February 11, 2022. His Super Bowl loss was a one possession game, and outside of the loss to Tampa, the Eagles had a chance late. In 12 seasons, he racked up 52 interceptions and also was a good return specialist. WebAnswer (1 of 18): Donovan McNabb is definitely not a Hall of Fame QB. Sorry, you couldn't help itbut no.". 13 on the all-time rushing yards list, right behind Jim Brown and Marshall Faulk and just ahead of Marcus Allen and Franco Harris. However, when looking at a player's entire career, how can we leave out how much they meant to a franchise, or even to an entire city? Delivery times may vary, especially during peak periods. Hall of Fame quarterbacks Jim Kelly and Dan Marino each scored a 15 and still ended up becoming one of the top quarterbacks of their era. I just continue to wait and see if it happens, it happens," McNabb said. McNair was an elite talent who wasn't into putting up numbers. great buying experience. McNabb, who turned 35 in November, has not won a Super Bowl ring and says fans don't look at him as a Hall of Fame-caliber player for that reason. " Before the stat was official, Karras had 97.5 sacks, which would put him one ahead of modern Hall of Famer Warren Sapp. Throughout his career, he was a top 10 QB in the game. There is some sentimentality here after McNairs tragic death 10 years ago, but he would be a fine representative fromthe Titans transition from the Oilers. If you think McNabb wouldnt have been as successful on that roster full of HOFers, youre just not being intellectually honest. NFL footage NFL Productions LLC. Sharpe played only seven seasons (all in Green Bay) in his 20s, but he made five Pro Bowls with three first-team All-Pro selections. While all of the incoming inductees are more than deserving, and many more from that decade soon to follow, its time to bring up one former Philadelphia Eagle who was a top five player in the NFL during that time, and has not received the credit, nor the popularity of others. Theres a case for other early Jaguars offensive stars like running back Fred Taylor and wide receiver Jimmy Smith, but its easy to go with the franchises first-ever draft pick. The Hall of Since I wrote that piece, Warren Moon became the first black quarterback to be inducted in Canton. To me, McNair was one of the best quarterbacks of his generation and one of the game's most respected performers for the bulk of his 13-year NFL career. Peyton He is also the New York Rangers beat reporter for AM New York. But when thinking of high-level edge pass-rushing, its easy to recall what Gastineau did from 1981-85. McNabb was excellent. A ninth would tie the Orange with Miami and Pitt for No. A player must have been retired at least five years before he can be considered for the Hall of Fame. This years Hall of Fame celebration dinner will be held at 6 p.m. June 22 at the Bakersfield College Renegade Event Center at 1801 Panorama Drive. He should be known for being an iron-man member of the Purple People Eaters, right there with Hall of Famers Alan Page and Carl Eller. ", -- "Aikman gave up numbers to win rings and hand the ball to @EmmittSmith22", -- "He had T.O. That averages to 85 catches, 1,162 yards and 9 TDs per season. who signed him to a 12-year contract in 2002, the first time a quarterback ever threw more than 30 touchdowns and fewer than 10 interceptions, McNabb became eligible for the NFL Hall of Fame in 2017, better than a lot of quarterbacks already in the Hall of Fame. Alexander played only eight seasons in Seattle before his knees slowed him down, but he made those years count. And it's numbers like these that have made several fans McNabb included confident that he belongs in Canton. McNabb, who has been eligible for the Pro Football Hall of Fame since 2016, had his No. File him under the Terrell Davis ethereal cases. Brown was also named to the Hall of Fames all-decade team in the 60s. "When they look at my numbers, yeah, but then they always want to add other stuff into it. And from 2004 to the end of his career in 2011, he turned in a truly outstanding TD-to-interception ratio of 147-to-68. When put into that perspective its pretty amazing. Ronde Barber is a legend in not only Tampa Bay football, but the game of football itself, and while the competition looks strong, its past the time the NFL enshrines him into the Hall of Fame. I found myself in the improbable position of defending Limbaugh at Slate. Kelly had the luxury of throwing to some of the greatest players in league history. He has never made it onto the actual ballot -- and now, Obviously, the NFL is still reeling from McNair's untimely death, and hearts and prayers are with his friends and family as they try to somehow cope with his passing. After nabbing both QB C.J. During his seven seasons in New Orleans, Swilling went to five Pro Bowls and made first-team All-Pro twice on the strength of 76.5 sacks. But the case for, I'd argue, is more persuasive. You won't want to miss a moment of the 2023 season! McNabb had to find ways to win playoff games without a true receiving threat for most of his career. Plenty of former NFL players believe they should be in the Hall of Fame, and whatever you think of McNabb's case, his willingness to compare his statisticsto the former Cowboys starsparked debateon Twitter. And it's numbers like these that have made several fans Multiple Super Bowl rings should not be a reason to put someone in the Hall of Fame, nor should it hold back a player who was unable to reach that plateau in the first place. He was drafted second overall and should be at least partly credited with the turnaround of the Eagles franchise. "What happens a lot of times is we look at what the list says, so we talk about the five NFC Championship Games, the six Pro Bowls and then we come to the end, 'Well, he never won the big game,'" McNabb told Mark Kriegel of FoxSports.com, via the Philadelphia Daily News. Who won the 2023 NFL Draft? It's not too early to call Patrick Mahomes a fairly sure thing for the Hall of Fame seeing as he's already getting some G.O.A.T. While players do so many different things in each sport, the easiest way to compare and judge all of them is by success. His long-time teammate and future brother-in-law Jason Taylor is a close second, but Thomas, the undersized, prolific tackling marvel, has to be the Dolphins top snub. He was a Pro Bowl and All-Pro fixture during that span. Cornerback Lester Hayes is a close second, with five of his 10 Raiders seasons being exceptional. Manning has a pair of rings, yet in the other four years he made the playoffs, he ended up losing without winning a playoff game. This is hypocrisy. The Eagles scored 17 touchdowns in 1998. Defensive tackle Kris Jenkins is close, but lets go with Walls, who made five Pro Bowls in his 30s as one of the NFLs best receiving tight ends in the late 1990s. Unfortunately for McNabb, his postseason record is also one of the biggest knocks on his career and on his candidacy for the Hall of Fame. But if you really look at his whole body of work, along with the context of who he was actually playing with, and STILL managing to win playoff games and Eagles passing records, then the asnwer is clear. Yet Aikman, who was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2006, played for three Super Bowl champions. 3. Hes also third in games played (353), fourth in extra points made (820), and third in career field goals (538). The Eagles went 5-11 in McNabb's first year, and he only threw eight touchdowns in his first 12 NFL games. See terms at draftkings.com/sportsbook. NFL and the NFL shield design are registered trademarks of the National Football League.The team names, logos and uniform designs are registered trademarks of the teams indicated. The three-time Pro Bowler rushed for 9,429 yards and 100 TDs. Notes - Delivery *Estimated delivery dates include seller's handling time, origin ZIP Code, destination ZIP Code and time of acceptance and will depend on shipping service selected and receipt of cleared payment. His 37,276 passing yards ranks #25 on the all time list with names like Dave Krieg and Kerry Collins ahead of him. Copyright 2023 Sporting News Holdings Limited. Lewis was named to the Pro Bowl and selected All-Pro in only one season, his 2,066-yard rushing explosion of 2003. No one should expect to make money from the picks and predictions discussed on this website. That group features 17 present or surefire Hall of Famers. "Well, Peyton never won the big game until he won the Super Bowl. I'm only including quarterbacks who have played more than five seasons to this point (guys such as Ben Roethlisberger, Eli Manning and Philip Rivers don't yet qualify). Should he be in the Hall because of his rings alone? Back in 1998, writing for ESPN Magazine, I touted McNabb, who had just played his final year at Syracuse, as the best college quarterback in the nation and hassled my editors into putting him on the cover of the first fall issue as the NFL's coming superstar. So how does one make the argument that Jim Kelly should be in the Hall, His Super Bowl loss was a one possession game. 2023 NFL Enterprises LLC. McNabb became eligible for the NFL Hall of Fame in 2017 and has been nominated each year since then. He also recorded two of the most prolific consecutive seasons in league history with 19 and 22 sacks in 1983 and 84, respectively. He completed 61 percent of his passes in that stretch for 25,760 yards and a solid, if unspectacular, 84.4 passer rating. Donovan McNabb. It is an absolutely solid class, with long-time nominees Cliff Branch and Dick Vermeil finally getting in amongst others. He's not a guy who'll likely get in right away, but he deserves serious consideration, and we'd expect to eventually see him as a Hall of Fame finalist. Anderson was in the league from 1982 to 2004, and the kicker is third on the career points list with 2,434. It's tough.". Adam Schein spotlights nine teams with exquisite prospect hauls. That added dynamic made him one of the most feared players in the NFL. McNabb was asked what makes a Hall of Famer: "First of all is his numbers. McNabb never had a dubious distinction like that? But it's not the be-all, end-all as a representation of an NFL player's greatness. Kriegel started the discussion by saying there would be "no debate" whether or not McNabb was a Hall of Famer if he had a title. So how does one make the argument that Jim Kelly should be in the Hall while McNabb doesnt? Stroud, 4 Anthony Richardson @NFLResearch Two decades and a 13-year career later and McNabb possesses the title as Throughout his career, he was a top 10 QB in the game. He was just the third Black quarterback to start in the Super Bowl when he was under center for the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl XXXIX. Over the course of his 13-year career, McNabb compiled 37,276 passing yards (25th all-time) and 234 passing TDs (31st), while collecting over 3,400 rushing yards and another 29 TDs on the ground. 1999: 1 Tim Couch, 2 Donovan McNabb, 3 Akili Smith 2021: 1 Trevor Lawrence, 2 Zach Wilson, 3 Trey Lance 2023: 1 Bryce Young, 2 C.J. He passed an average of 8.3 yards/throw. Patton was the games most dominant defensive back for a five-year stretch from 1958-62 after helping the Giants win an NFL championship in 1956. The defense carried this team [the Eagles].". Please also read our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use, which became effective December 20, 2019. I understand that, and I'm not saying that McNair is a sure thing (frankly, my gut is that he won't get in). If he makes it in, McNabb needs to wear this hat. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER. A team with zero Super Bowls and only a little bit of success throughout history would go on to make four straight NFC championships and become a dominant force in the NFC. He even lost a playoff game to McNabb in 2008 as a #1 seed! Donovan McNabb started his own campaign for the Pro Football Hall of Fame last week on the day the Eagles retired his number. But in the meantime, good luck to McNabb and Anderson this time around. The fact McNabb went to five Conference Championship Games in his 10 years as a starter in Philadelphia makes him Hall-of-Fame worthy. Anderson also was respected off the field after spending 16 seasons in Cincinnati. Eli has two more rings, but the Hall of Fame shouldn't be all about rings. Schafrath was an elite blocking guard and tackle in the 1960s for several prolific rushing teams, including the short-but-brilliant career of Jim Brown, the best running back in NFL history. McNabb has always been a favorite of mine. "But, people don't realize how hard it is to get to the NFC Championship and to get there five times, and then make it to a Super Bowl?
Warwick School Board Election Lititz, Pa,
Articles W